Government spending

"Public Purse" redirects here. For the term used in relation to the British monarchy, see Privy Purse.

Government spending (or government expenditure) includes all government consumption, investment but excludes transfer payments[1] made by a state. Government acquisition of goods and services for current use to directly satisfy individual or collective needs of the members of the community is classed as government final consumption expenditure. Government acquisition of goods and services intended to create future benefits, such as infrastructure investment or research spending, is classed as government investment (gross fixed capital formation), which usually is the largest part of the government gross capital formation. Acquisition of goods and services is made through own production by the government (using the government's labour force, fixed assets and purchased goods and services for intermediate consumption) or through purchases of goods and services from market producers. Government expenditures that are not acquisition of goods and services, and instead just represent transfers of money, such as social security payments, are called transfer payments. Government spending can be financed by seigniorage, taxes, or government borrowing.

The first two types of government spending, namely government final consumption expenditure and government gross capital formation, together constitute one of the major components of gross domestic product.

John Maynard Keynes was one of the first economists to advocate government deficit spending as part of the fiscal policy response to an economic contraction. In Keynesian economics, increased government spending is thought to raise aggregate demand and increase consumption, which in turn leads to increased production. Keynesian economists argue that the Great Depression was ended by government spending programs such as the New Deal and military spending during World War II. According to the Keynesian view, a severe recession or depression may never end if the government does not intervene.

Classical economists and Austrian economists, on the other hand, believe that increased government spending exacerbates an economic contraction by shifting resources from the private sector, which they consider productive, to the public sector, which they consider unproductive. According to Austrian economists, the reason the Great Depression lasted as long as it did was because of significant government spending and government regulation of the economy.

Contents

United States of America

Government spending in the United States of America occurs at several levels of government, including primarily federal, state, and local governments. The United States Census Bureau publishes an overview of government spending every year in the Statistical Abstract of the United States[2]

At the time of this entry, the most recent year for which actual spending for all levels of government has been reported. Overall government spending for all levels of government in the United States of America was as follows: (The following table represents non-government data analysis. Published spending reports can be found here historical tables.)

United States Federal, State,
and Local Government Spending
Fiscal Year 2010
Function Amount
(billion)
Percent
GDP
Overall government spending
Federal, State, Local $5,798.8 39.97
Spending by major government function
Pensions $939.2 6.47
Health Care $1028.8 7.09
Education $887.3 6.12
Defense $848.1 5.85
Welfare $727.3 5.01
Interest $296.3 2.04

Government spending expressed as a percent of Gross Domestic Product is based on a total of $14,660.4 billion for calendar year 2010 reported by the Bureau of Economic Analysis.[3]

Federal Spending

As of September 2004 the U.S. Congressional Budget Office reported that federal government spending for 2004 was projected to be $2.293 trillion, or slightly less than 20% of the GDP. Of that, $646.7 billion was for net interest, $486 billion for defense, $492 billion for Social Security, $473 billion for Medicare and Medicaid, $191 billion for various welfare programs, $136 billion for "retirement and disability" benefits, and $64 billion was projected to be spent elsewhere.

There are two types of government spending — discretionary and mandatory. Discretionary spending, which accounts for roughly one-third of all Federal spending, includes money for things like the Army, FBI, the Coast Guard, and highway projects. Congress explicitly determines how much to spend (or not spend) on these programs on an annual basis. Mandatory spending accounts for two-thirds of all government spending. This kind of spending is authorized by permanent laws. It includes Insurance programs like Social Security, Medicare/Medicaid, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, and federal retirement and disability programs that provide benefits to federal civilian employees, members of the military, and veterans. — programs through which individuals receive benefits based on their age, income, or other criteria. Spending levels in these areas are dictated by the number of people who sign up for these benefits, rather than by Congress.

State and Local Spending

The United States Census Bureau conducts a census of State and Local Government Finances every five years and updates the census every year. The latest fiscal year reported by the Census Bureau is 2006.

US History

The United States Census Bureau publishes historical data series on government spending in the United States in its Statistical Abstract of the United States[4] and in its special release of historical statistics in 1976 at the time of the US Bicentennial.[5]

Over the last century starting overall government spending in the United States has increased substantially from about seven percent of GDP in 1902 to about 35 percent of GDP in 2010. Major spikes in spending occurred in World War I and World War II.

When broken down by major function, the history of US government spending as a percent of GDP shows a slow and consistent increase in education spending; it shows the spikes in defense spending during World War I and World War II, and the sustained high level maintained during the Cold War. Spending on welfare shows a clear takeoff during the Great Depression and a modest decline following reform in 1996. Spending on pensions (primarily Social Security) begins to show up in the 1950s. Health care spending takes off after the birth of Medicare and Medicaid in the 1960s and shows sustained growth ever since.

US Government Spending Patterns

Divided vs. United Government

In an interview with Charlie Rose, Milton Friedman noted that US government spending declines fastest when Democrats control the executive branch while Republicans control the legislature.[6]

Referencing accounts from the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the voting record, it can be seen that US government spending typically declines as a percentage of GDP when no party controls both the executive and legislative branches.

National Government Spending Per Capita

In 2010, the Federal government of the USA spent an average of $11,041 per citizen (per capita). This compares to the 2010 World average spending of $2376 per citizen and an average of $16,110 per citizen for the World's 20 largest economies (in terms of GDP). Of the 20 largest economies, only six spent less per citizen: South Korea ($4557), Brazil ($2813), Russia ($2458), China ($1010), and India ($$226). Of the 13 that spent more, Norway and Sweden top the list with per citizen spending of $40908 and $26760 respectively.[8]

Government spending as a percentage of GDP

This is a list of countries by government spending as a percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) for the listed countries, according to the 2011 Index of Economic Freedom[9] by The Heritage Foundation and The Wall Street Journal. Tax revenue is included for comparison.

Country Tax burden % GDP Govt. expend. % GDP
 Albania 24.3 32.3
 Algeria 8.0 35.4
 Angola 6.1 41.6
 Argentina 26.1 24.7
 Armenia 16.8 21.8
 Australia 30.8 34.3
 Austria 42.9 49.0
 Azerbaijan 17.7 31.1
 Bahamas 16.8 20.9
 Bahrain 4.8 25.7
 Bangladesh 8.8 15.9
 Barbados 32.9 41.3
 Belarus 30.4 49.6
 Belgium 46.5 50.0
 Belize 22.7 28.2
 Benin 17.2 23.0
 Bhutan 9.0 34.6
 Bolivia 28.5 34.8
 Bosnia and Herzegovina 37.6 50.3
 Botswana 30.2 40.2
 Brazil 34.4 41.0
 Bulgaria 33.3 37.3
 Burkina Faso 12.1 21.6
 Burma 3.0 8.0
 Burundi 18.0 40.0
 Cambodia 10.5 13.9
 Cameroon 18.5 18.5
 Canada 32.2 39.7
 Cape Verde 20.6 31.1
 Central African Republic 7.9 15.5
 Chad 5.3 22.1
 Chile 18.6 21.1
 China 18.0 20.8
 Colombia 19.3 26.5
 Comoros 10.8 27.2
 Congo 5.3 26.0
 Democratic Republic of the Congo 13.1 22.7
 Costa Rica 15.6 20.9
 Côte d'Ivoire 15.2 19.7
 Croatia 23.3 40.7
 Cuba 41.2 78.1
 Cyprus 39.2 42.6
 Czech Republic 36.2 42.9
 Denmark 49.0 51.8
 Djibouti 22.7 40.6
 Dominica 30.4 42.5
 Dominican Republic 15.0 19.1
 Ecuador 16.0 40.8
 Egypt 15.4 34.0
 El Salvador 13.0 20.0
 Equatorial Guinea 0.9 25.5
 Estonia 32.3 39.9
 Ethiopia 9.9 19.4
 Fiji 21.1 25.0
 Finland 43.2 49.5
 France 44.6 52.8
 Gabon 9.9 20.1
 Gambia 19.2 26.0
 Georgia 24.9 36.4
 Germany 40.6 43.7
 Ghana 20.6 42.4
 Greece 35.1 46.8
 Guatemala 11.3 13.7
 Guinea 14.7 17.4
 Guinea-Bissau 10.2 38.8
 Guyana 20.2 48.6
 Haiti 10.3 18.2
 Honduras 16.3 21.8
 Hong Kong 13.0 18.6
 Hungary 40.5 49.2
 Iceland 40.1 57.8
 India 18.6 27.2
 Indonesia 13.3 19.2
 Iran 6.1 28.3
 Ireland 30.8 42.0
 Israel 33.5 42.9
 Italy 43.1 48.8
 Jamaica 26.0 34.3
 Japan 28.3 37.1
 Jordan 18.3 36.1
 Kazakhstan 27.7 26.8
 Kenya 20.9 30.1
 Kiribati[10] 39.0 114.6
 Kuwait 1.5 31.8
 Kyrgyzstan 23.3 29.3
 Laos 12.5 18.2
 Latvia 29.1 38.5
 Lebanon 16.6 34.2
 Lesotho 63.1 51.2
 Liberia 28.6 33.4
 Libya 3.4 43.0
 Lithuania 30.6 37.4
 Luxembourg 36.5 37.2
 Macau 25.9 14.9
 Macedonia 28.3 34.5
 Madagascar 12.9 18.5
 Malawi 16.5 38.0
 Malaysia 15.3 26.3
 Maldives 21.0 63.1
 Mali 15.0 21.2
 Malta 36.0 44.8
 Mauritania 13.4 29.5
 Mauritius 19.0 25.8
 Mexico 8.2 23.7
 Federated States of Micronesia 11.5 62.3
 Moldova 33.4 41.6
 Mongolia 30.8 41.0
 Montenegro 30.0 48.8
 Morocco 26.9 29.1
 Mozambique 14.2 28.0
 Namibia 24.8 29.0
 Netherlands 39.8 45.9
 Nepal 10.4 19.7
 New Zealand 34.5 41.1
 Nicaragua 18.0 25.0
 Niger 11.4 23.8
 Nigeria 5.9 30.0
 Norway 42.1 40.2
 Oman 3.0 32.6
 Pakistan 10.2 19.3
 Panama 10.6 19.5
 Papua New Guinea 26.6 35.0
 Paraguay 11.8 14.8
 Peru 16.0 17.3
 Philippines 14.1 17.3
 Poland 34.9 43.3
 Portugal 37.7 46.1
 Qatar 4.9 27.0
 Romania 28.5 37.6
 Russia 34.1 34.1
 Rwanda 13.5 26.7
 Saint Lucia 27.5 30.9
 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 25.6 34.1
 Samoa 23.0 32.7
 São Tomé and Príncipe 16.1 32.9
 Saudi Arabia 6.6 29.1
 Senegal 18.3 26.6
 Serbia 36.3 44.0
 Seychelles 28.1 39.8
 Sierra Leone 10.8 21.0
 Singapore 14.2 17.0
 Slovakia 29.3 34.8
 Slovenia 37.6 44.3
 Solomon Islands 24.1 47.3
 South Africa 25.7 27.4
 South Korea 26.6 30.0
 Spain 33.9 41.1
 Sri Lanka 13.3 22.6
 Suriname 21.1 25.6
 Swaziland 36.0 33.7
 Sweden 47.9 52.5
 Switzerland 29.4 32.0
 Syria 10.2 22.1
 Taiwan 12.9 18.5
 Tajikistan 18.7 27.5
 Tanzania 14.8 25.5
 Thailand 16.0 17.7
 Timor-Leste[11] [12] [13] 24.6 97.0
 Togo 16.3 19.5
 Tonga 25.7 29.9
 Trinidad and Tobago 19.4 28.4
 Tunisia 22.4 27.3
 Turkey 23.5 23.4
 Turkmenistan 21.8 12.3
 Uganda 11.9 17.8
 Ukraine 37.7 47.3
 United Arab Emirates 1.8 26.4
 United Kingdom 38.9 47.3
 United States 26.9 38.9
 Uruguay 17.9 28.0
 Uzbekistan 19.6 31.1
 Vanuatu 19.7 26.4
 Venezuela 13.6 34.0
 Vietnam 23.6 28.8
 Yemen 7.3 43.0
 Zambia 17.5 24.6
 Zimbabwe 31.7 97.8

See also

References

External links